how hard should you push back
First, I've just committed one of the mortal sins of blogging—not posting every day, or at least three times a week. Frankly, I don't know how others do it without a staff. I'm slaving to finish my book edits, designing my author's website, laying the foundation for my foundation—and taking care of three boys, my husband, an 8-year-old and a soon-to-be-10-year-old.
But, I'm back, and before I offer today's tip, let me share some good news. My manuscript was accepted last week, so the presses will be rolling soon. I'm relieved, and though I expect more questions from my editor, the last set were rather painless, compared to the monumental self-editing job I had to do the last time, which brings me to today's topic: How much should you resist your editor's edits?
You absolutely cannot fall in love with your writing, or you won't be able to get past deleting copy that you think is just the greatest prose. Your editor's job is to frame your book. For readers to keep turning pages, he or she needs words of engagement, and that is accomplished by how your frame each chapter. For me, I had to eliminate the running memoir and instead open up with a strong vignette that tied back to the advice at the end of each chapter.
At first, I grumbled, but I defered. She's done this like a gazillion times before. Nonetheless, I got my agent involved. That's what your agent is for, to mediate difference. On the one hand, I wanted to be done. I've been working on this book for two years. Another part of me, the practical part, realized that editors are under pressure from not only their bosses but from the marketing and sales departments. So, sometimes what you had outlined in your book proposal will change.
That's what happened to me. In the end, my editor made my book stronger, and I'm thankful for that. Hey, we all want to sell as many books as possible, right?